Comparing ThreatDown Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) by Malwarebytes and Webroot Business Endpoint Protection involves evaluating their features, performance, ease of use, and suitability for different business needs. Below is a detailed comparison based on available information:
- Overview
- ThreatDown EDR (Malwarebytes):
- A comprehensive endpoint security solution combining endpoint protection (EPP) and endpoint detection and response (EDR).
- Designed for organizations of all sizes, particularly those with limited IT resources, offering simple deployment and management.
- Emphasizes advanced threat detection, automated remediation, and ransomware rollback capabilities.
- Backed by Malwarebytes’ global threat intelligence and patented remediation engine.
- Webroot Business Endpoint Protection:
- A cloud-based, lightweight endpoint security solution focused on small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and managed service providers (MSPs).
- Leverages machine learning and behavioral analysis for threat detection, with a focus on minimal system impact and rapid deployment.
- Known for its small footprint and integration with remote monitoring and management (RMM) tools.
- Key Features Comparison
| Feature | ThreatDown EDR | Webroot Business Endpoint Protection |
| Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) | Full EDR capabilities, including real-time threat hunting, behavioral analytics, and anomaly detection. | Limited EDR capabilities; primarily focuses on endpoint protection with basic behavioral detection. |
| Ransomware Protection | 7-day ransomware rollback to restore files encrypted, deleted, or modified. | Claims some rollback capability but lacks robust file recovery, requiring manual intervention. |
| Threat Detection | Combines AI, machine learning, heuristics, and rules-based techniques for proactive threat detection. | Uses behavioral analysis and cloud-based threat intelligence; effective for known threats but less advanced for zero-day attacks. |
| Remediation | Patented Linking Engine removes all malware traces and prevents reinfection. Automated remediation included. | Automated remediation is less comprehensive; may require manual cleanup for complex threats. |
| Security Advisor | Includes Security Advisor for security posture scoring and automated guidance to improve defenses. | No equivalent feature; lacks automated guidance for optimizing security settings. |
| Device Support | Supports Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, and ChromeOS. | Supports Windows and macOS; limited mobile and Linux support. |
| Additional Features | Application block, vulnerability assessment, patch management, DNS filtering, device control. | DNS filtering included; lacks vulnerability assessment, patch management, or device control. |
| Management Console | OneView platform for MSPs, cloud-based, multi-tenant console for centralized management. | Cloud-based centralized console, integrates well with RMM tools like ConnectWise Automate. |
| Performance Impact | Lightweight agent with negligible system resource impact. | Extremely lightweight, minimal resource usage, ideal for low-resource environments. |
- Performance and Effectiveness
- ThreatDown EDR:
- Consistently earns top rankings, including Level 1 certification in MRG Effitas 360-degree testing and #1 Endpoint Security Suite by G2.
-
- Achieved a perfect score in AVLab’s January 2024 real-world malware detection tests for 11 consecutive quarters, outperforming competitors like Webroot, which missed samples in the same test.
-
- Excels in detecting and blocking advanced threats, including zero-day attacks, due to its AI-driven and behavioral analytics approach.
-
- Found and removed threats on 39% of devices with another antivirus installed, indicating strong detection capabilities.
- Webroot Business Endpoint Protection:
- Scored highest (84/100) in a 2019 PassMark review of nine security products, excelling in installation size, scan times, and resource usage.
-
- Effective for basic threats (viruses, malware, spyware) but less robust against sophisticated attacks due to limited EDR capabilities.
-
- Behavioral detection relies on cloud-based analysis, which may struggle with unknown threats compared to ThreatDown’s multi-layered approach.
-
- Earned top scores in PCMag’s hands-on tests but doesn’t always perform well in automated lab tests due to its non-traditional detection style.
- Ease of Use and Deployment
- ThreatDown EDR:
- Voted “Easiest to Use” on G2, with a fast setup time (up to half the time of competitors) and intuitive UI.
-
- Single, lightweight agent simplifies deployment and management, especially for MSPs using the OneView platform.
-
- Some users note the dashboard can feel clunky initially but becomes manageable with familiarity.
- Webroot Business Endpoint Protection:
- Extremely fast deployment (installs in seconds) and minimal system impact, making it ideal for SMEs with limited IT resources.
-
- Cloud-based console is easy to navigate and integrates seamlessly with RMM tools, enhancing MSP efficiency.
-
- Some users report challenges with updating software exceptions, particularly in healthcare settings, requiring support intervention.
- User Satisfaction and Reviews
- ThreatDown EDR:
- G2 rating: 4.69/5 (123 reviews).
-
- Overall satisfaction score of 92.15, ahead of competitors like Webroot.
-
- Praised for ease of use, powerful threat detection, and robust remediation but criticized for lacking advanced AI-based proactive threat hunting.
-
- Some users note pricing may feel high for smaller organizations with limited budgets.
- Webroot Business Endpoint Protection:
- G2 rating: 4.53/5 (15 reviews).
-
- Highly rated for ease of setup, ongoing support, and meeting SME needs, but slightly lower than ThreatDown in overall satisfaction.
-
- Users appreciate its lightweight design and proactive protection but note limitations in advanced threat detection and occasional support dependency.
- Pricing
- ThreatDown EDR:
- Pricing is not publicly listed but available through quotes on the ThreatDown website (https://x.ai/grok).[](https://www.wheelhouse.com/compare/threatdown-vs-webroot)
- Offers multiple bundles (Core, Advanced, Elite) with increasing features, which may increase costs but provide flexibility.
-
- Some users perceive pricing as less justified for smaller organizations compared to Webroot.
- Webroot Business Endpoint Protection:
- Pricing starts at $49.99/year for one device, $69.99 for three devices, and $89.99 for five devices.
-
- Generally considered more affordable than ThreatDown, especially for small businesses with basic security needs.
-
- Integrates cost-effectively with MSP workflows due to RMM compatibility.
- Suitability
- ThreatDown EDR:
- Best for: Organizations needing advanced EDR, ransomware protection, and cross-platform support (including Linux, mobile, and ChromeOS).
- Ideal for businesses with growing security needs, MSPs managing multiple clients, or those prioritizing automated remediation and security posture optimization.
- Suitable for environments facing sophisticated threats due to its robust detection and response capabilities.
- Webroot Business Endpoint Protection:
- Best for: SMEs and MSPs with limited IT resources seeking lightweight, affordable, and easy-to-deploy endpoint protection.
- Ideal for businesses focused on basic malware protection and integration with existing RMM tools.
- Less suitable for organizations requiring advanced EDR or protection for diverse device types (e.g., Linux or mobile).
- Critical Considerations
- ThreatDown EDR:
- Strengths: Superior EDR capabilities, ransomware rollback, cross-platform support, and top-tier performance in independent tests.
- Weaknesses: Potentially higher cost and less focus on AI-driven proactive threat hunting compared to some competitors.
-
- Critical Note: Its comprehensive feature set may be overkill for very small businesses with basic needs.
- Webroot Business Endpoint Protection:
- Strengths: Lightweight, affordable, and fast to deploy, with strong performance for basic threat protection and MSP integration.
- Weaknesses: Limited EDR capabilities, weaker ransomware recovery, and less support for non-Windows/macOS devices.
-
- Critical Note: May not suffice for organizations facing advanced or persistent threats due to its focus on prevention over response.
- Recommendation
- Choose ThreatDown EDR if:
- You need advanced EDR for detecting and responding to sophisticated threats.
- Ransomware rollback and automated remediation are critical for your business.
- You manage a diverse device ecosystem (e.g., Linux, mobile, ChromeOS) or multiple clients as an MSP.
- You prioritize top-tier performance validated by independent tests like AVLab and MRG Effitas.
- Choose Webroot Business Endpoint Protection if:
- You’re a small business or MSP with limited IT resources and budget.
- You need a lightweight, cloud-based solution with minimal system impact.
- Your primary focus is basic malware protection and integration with RMM tools.
- You don’t require advanced EDR or support for non-Windows/macOS devices.
- Conclusion
ThreatDown EDR offers a more robust and feature-rich solution, excelling in advanced threat detection, ransomware protection, and cross-platform support, making it ideal for businesses with complex security needs. Webroot Business Endpoint Protection, while effective for basic protection, is better suited for smaller organizations prioritizing simplicity, affordability, and low resource usage. Evaluate your organization’s threat landscape, device types, and budget to determine the best fit.
If you’d like a deeper analysis of specific features, user reviews, or assistance with decision-making, let me know!